Where to Book your Nantucket Rental for Summer 2026
How do you know which Nantucket neighborhood is right for you?
How do you know which Nantucket neighborhood is right for you?
Planning a Nantucket getaway is one of the most exciting parts of summer. The island offers a diverse mix of neighborhoods, each with its own character, charm, and lifestyle. If you’re new to vacationing in the area, you may feel overwhelmed with options and are curious about which neighborhood is best for you. Whether you’re looking for a beachside retreat, a family-friendly area with easy access to town, or a quiet corner surrounded by nature, Nantucket has a neighborhood that fits your vacation style. Here’s a guide to help you decide where to book your summer rental.
If you want to be in the heart of it all, Town is the place to stay. This area is ideal for those who love to walk to shops, restaurants, and the harbor. Renting here means easy access to downtown favorites like The Juice Bar, Straight Wharf, and the charming cobblestone streets. Beaches like Jetties and Children’s Beach are just a short walk or bike ride away, making it perfect for families and visitors who want a car-free vacation.
Brant Point is one of Nantucket’s most iconic and convenient neighborhoods. It’s just minutes from Town and the ferry docks, yet it feels like a quiet beachside enclave. Many rentals here offer water views and quick access to Brant Point Lighthouse and Jetties Beach. It’s a top choice for those who want both proximity to Town and an easy stroll to the beach.
On the opposite end of the island, Sconset offers a peaceful, storybook setting that is quintessential Nantucket. This historic village is known for its rose-covered cottages and bluffs overlooking the Atlantic, and its charming local eateries like Claudette’s and The Chanticleer. Sconset is perfect for those seeking tranquility, ocean views, and access to some of the island’s most scenic walking trails. The Milestone bike path connects Sconset to Town, making it a great option for cyclists.
Surfside is a family favorite for its long stretches of sandy beach and easygoing vibe. The area is filled with vacation homes just a short walk or bike ride from the ocean. Surfside Beach has lifeguards, food trucks, and convenient parking, making it a great spot for beach days. Bike paths lead directly into Town, and it’s close enough to reach restaurants and shops while still feeling relaxed and spacious.
For stunning sunsets and an authentic Nantucket experience, Madaket is hard to beat. Located on the western end of the island, it’s quieter and more remote than other areas, ideal for nature lovers and those who want to unwind. Madaket Beach offers some of the best ocean views on the island, and you can grab dinner at Millie’s after a day by the water. The bike path from Town to Madaket is one of the most scenic routes on the island.
Dionis is a peaceful area just west of Town, known for calm beaches that are perfect for swimming and paddleboarding. It’s close enough to downtown for convenience but offers a quieter, more private setting. The beaches here face the Nantucket Sound, providing gentle surf and beautiful views. Dionis is great for families and anyone looking for a balance between beach access and proximity to amenities.
Naushop is a popular neighborhood for families and groups who prefer modern conveniences. Located mid-island, it’s not directly on the beach but offers easy access to Surfside and Town. Rentals here often come with community amenities like tennis courts, a swimming pool, and bike paths that connect to various parts of the island. It’s a great option for an active, family-friendly vacation.
Cisco: Known for its surf beach, brewery, and farm, Cisco is perfect for those who love adventure and local flavor.
Miacomet: Offers easy access to both the beach and Miacomet Golf Course, ideal for golfers and outdoor enthusiasts.
Madequecham: A secluded area on the south shore, great for those seeking privacy and dramatic ocean views.
Polpis and Quaise: These inland neighborhoods provide a mix of open space, conservation land, and access to Nantucket Harbor, perfect for nature lovers.
When choosing where to book your Nantucket rental, consider what matters most to you.
Beach access: Brant Point, Surfside, Dionis, and Madaket are closest to the coast.
Proximity to Town: Brant Point, Town, Naushop and Mid-Island offer the easiest access to shops and restaurants.
Biking and nature: Sconset, Madaket, and Polpis have some of the island’s best bike paths and scenic trails.
Pro tips: If you love a stunning beach sunset, Madaket is the place for you. If sunrise is more your style, Sconset Beach is the best the island has to offer.
No matter which neighborhood you choose, Nantucket’s beauty, charm, and coastal allure make every stay unforgettable.
To read more about each neighborhood, visit our Neighborhoods Page.
