An Insider's Guide to Dining in Nantucket
Nantucket's dining scene is world class and diverse. Our agents share their favorite spots.
Nantucket's dining scene is world class and diverse. Our agents share their favorite spots.
Whether you’re in the mood for a five-course meal, or just need a quick bite to eat, Nantucket offers a wide array of dining options. Renowned for its fresh seafood, clambakes, lobster bakes and Nantucket cranberry pie, the island boasts more restaurants than one would expect for its compact size. Stroll along the downtown Nantucket streets and you’ll find everything from upscale East Coast fare to lowkey pub food.
Our William Raveis Nantucket agents have shared some of their favorites with us.
The Chanticleer – Originally opened as a small tea house at the turn of the century, The Chanticleer is now one of the premier restaurants on Nantucket. One of the most romantic destinations on the island, you may linger over an intimate lunch in the Rose Garden or come together with family and friends for a convivial dinner in one of our personal dining rooms- al fresco on warm evenings. The lush gardens produce organic herbs, flowers, berries and seasonal vegetables for the kitchen. An extensive wine list features some of the finest wines in the world.
Chef Jeff Worster creates seasonal menus celebrating New England’s abundant local offerings from land and sea with a firm anchor in classic techniques and a penchant for cross cultural meanderings to all corners of the globe.
Neighborhood: Sconset
“The gardens are beautiful in July and the Grill Room is intimate in the winter.”
Robin Slick
William Raveis
Claudette’s Sandwiches – A beloved local sandwich shop located in Sconset, Claudette’s is known for its fresh, made-to-order, hearty sandwiches and casual, friendly atmosphere. Claudette’s has been a staple in the Sconset community for decades, attracting both locals and visitors who want to enjoy a quick, delicious meal before heading to the beach or exploring the charming village.
Neighborhood: Sconset
“I love the turkey salad sandwich with the works from Claudette’s.”
Robin Slick
William Raveis
Company of the Cauldron – An intimate, fine-dining restaurant located in Town, Company of the Cauldron is known for its cozy, romantic ambiance and pri-fixe menus, offering a unique dining experience with an emphasis on local, seasonal ingredients. The restaurant is set in a charming historic building, and its small size gives it an exclusive, intimate feel, making it perfect for special occasions or a quiet evening out.
Neighborhood: Town
“Company of the Cauldron is one of my favorite restaurants on the island for its intimate atmosphere and the Beef Wellington!”
Robin Trovato
William Raveis
Oran Mor – Known for its cozy, intimate atmosphere, Oran Mor offers a fine dining experience with a focus on contemporary American cuisine. The restaurant is celebrated for its seasonal, locally-sourced ingredients, creative dishes, and an ever-evolving menu that showcases Nantucket’s coastal offerings. Their wine list is also extensive and thoughtfully curated, making it a favorite among wine enthusiasts.
Neighborhood: Downtown
“I love Oran Mor for its ambiance for an intimate dining experience and a charming small bar"
Robin Slick
William Raveis
Misogi Noodle Bar – Owned by local Chef Felino Samson, former chef-owner of The Beet, Misogi Noodle Bar is a new concept utilizing the Southeast Asian cuisines of Philippines, Vietnam, Thailand, and Japan. The newly renovated dining room brings Japan to Nantucket, with an Asian themed lounge, reminiscent of an Izakaya, offering a polished yet casual atmosphere.
Neighborhood: Mid-Island
“Misogi Noodle Bar is a new spot in Town with chic atmosphere. Mussels and the chicken burger are to die for!”
Robin Slick
William Raveis
The Nantucket Tap Room – The Nantucket Tap Room is a classic American tavern-style restaurant located in the Jared Coffin House, at 29 Broad Street in downtown Nantucket. It has a welcoming, laid-back atmosphere and is known for offering hearty pub fare, including burgers, sandwiches, chowders, and fresh seafood. The Tap Room has a history on the island as a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike, offering a comfortable and cozy space with a focus on comfort food and drinks.
Neighborhood: Downtown
“I love the Tap Room for its ambiance and cozy feeling, lending itself as a place to meet in the off season and reconnect after the busy season.”
Sue Jemison
William Raveis
Le Languedoc – Established in 1976, the Languedoc is an institution on Nantucket; owners Alan and Ann Cunha, Neil Grennan and Eddie Grennan have been at the helm for almost 48 years. Enjoy a casual dinner in the café or a more refined dining experience in the upstairs dining room. Le Languedoc’s cuisine is based on classic French techniques with an influence of Nantucket, New England and around the world. While the menu is seasonal, Le Languedoc is specifically known for Nantucket classics like, soft shell crabs and shad roe in the spring, Bartlett Farm tomatoes and corn in the summer, and Nantucket Bay scallops and black truffles in the winter.
“Best Steak Frites and cozy atmosphere.”
Jenny Gifford
William Raveis
Millie’s – A true Nantucket treasure and institution, Mille’s is named after island legend, “Madaket Millie” Jewett, who spent her life caring for the beaches, the animals and the people of Madaket. Known for its laidback style and coastal fare, Millie’s features both New England style lobster rolls and California Baja-style fish tacos. And don’t forget to visit at sunset and follow up your meal with ice cream.
Neighborhood: Madaket
“I love Madaket Millie’s for the food, local feeling and fantastic sunsets.”
Sue Jemison
William Raveis
The Summer House – While technically one of Nantucket’s boutique hotels, the Summer House is also home to two of the island’s best restaurants, The Summer House Restaurant – overlooking the ocean with its famous piano bar, and the Beachside Bistro – with outdoor seating nestled in the dunes on the beach.
Neighborhood: Sconset
“The Summerhouse Bistro by the pool is a gorgeous setting and the owner is a dear friend of mine, love it there! Lots of great memories made there.”
Beth Jekanowski
William Raveis
Ventuno – An upscale Italian restaurant located in the heart of Nantucket, Ventuno offers a sophisticated dining experience with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients inspired by classic Italian cuisine. The menu features house-made pastas, fresh seafood, and creative dishes that highlight the island’s local produce. Ventuno is known for its warm ambiance, ideal for both casual dining and special occasions.
Neighborhood: Downtown
“Ventuno for dinner because the service, food, and ambience are always top notch."
Melanie Gowen
William Raveis
Lemon Press – Inspired by owner’s upbringing and heritage, Lemon Press is a vibrant Persian-inspired café and restaurant in Downtown Nantucket, known for its healthy and creative menu offerings. The restaurant focuses on fresh, locally sourced ingredients with a strong emphasis on organic and sustainable options.
Neighborhood: Downtown
“I love Lemon Press for their healthy juices, lunch, and coffee because I designed it!”
Melanie Gowen
William Raveis
Galley Beach – A renowned waterfront restaurant located on Cliff Road in Nantucket, Galley Beach offers a unique dining experience with stunning ocean views. Known for its upscale, beach-chic atmosphere, it is one of the island’s most iconic spots, particularly popular for its beautiful sunset views and beachside location.
Neighborhood: Cliff
“Head to Galley beach for sunset drinks because the vibe at sunset is magical.”
Melanie Gowen
William Raveis
Straight Warf Restaurant – Located on the waterfront in downtown Nantuket, Straight Warf has been a Nantucket staple for six decades. The restaurant's menu evolves nightly, reflecting seasonal availability and the freshest local produce. Signature dishes include scallops, clams, and local Nantucket fluke.
"Straight Wharf Restaurant has a wonderful vibe located on the wharf with nice water views. The food and service are outstanding.”
Robin Trovato
William Raveis
Cisco Brewers – The perfect place to wind down after a day at the beach, Cisco Brewers has been a staple in the Nantucket community for almost 30 years. While primarily known for its craft beer, wine, and spirits, Cisco Brewers also hosts a rotating selection of food trucks. These trucks offer a range of casual fare, from lobster rolls and tacos to BBQ and burgers. The relaxed outdoor environment, live music, and great drinks make it one of the most popular spots on the island.
Neighborhood: Cisco
“Comedy night or the live music at Cisco is always part of a perfect day on Nantucket.”
Robin Slick
William Raveis
Something Natural – A beloved local institution, Something Natural is a casual spot known for its sandwiches made with freshly baked bread. Located on Cliff Road, it’s a great place to stop for lunch or grab food to take to the beach.
Neighborhood: Cliff
“My perfect day on the island includes stopping at Something Natural or in town for a treat on the way home from a walk with my dog.”
Melanie Gowen
William Raveis
