Best Nantucket Neighborhoods for a Luxury Summer Rental
Compare Nantucket's premier luxury neighborhoods.
Compare Nantucket's premier luxury neighborhoods.
A luxury home on Nantucket isn't measured by square footage alone. The best luxury summer rental homes combine privacy, thoughtful design, exceptional outdoor living, and a location that lets you experience the island the way you have always dreamed about. For some, that means walking to dinner in Town, while for others, it's waking up to water views, spending afternoons by the pool, or having the beach in their backyard.
If you're searching for a luxury Nantucket rental or a luxury home to buy, these six neighborhoods consistently offer some of the island's most sought-after homes, including many exclusive William Raveis properties.
If someone pictures a luxury Nantucket estate, there's a good chance they're imagining the Cliff.
Just west of Town, the neighborhood is known for grand homes tucked behind mature hedges, beautifully landscaped grounds, private pools, and easy access to Steps Beach. Many properties sit on larger lots than you'll find closer to downtown, creating a sense of privacy that's hard to match while still being just a short bike ride or walk from Main Street.
Luxury renters choose the Cliff for:
If your perfect vacation includes sunset cocktails by the pool followed by dinner in Town, the Cliff checks every box.
Brant Point offers one of the most coveted addresses on Nantucket.
Located between Town and Nantucket Harbor, this neighborhood lets you leave the car behind. You can walk to restaurants, boutiques, Children's Beach, Jetties Beach, the ferry, and the iconic Brant Point Lighthouse in just minutes.
Luxury homes here often feature elegant coastal interiors, harbor views, beautifully designed outdoor spaces, and enough room for extended families without sacrificing convenience.
Brant Point is ideal for guests who want:
Monomoy offers a quieter side of luxury.
Located east of Town, the neighborhood is known for waterfront estates overlooking Nantucket Harbor and the surrounding creeks. Many homes feature private docks or easy water access, making this one of the island's favorite locations for boating enthusiasts.
You'll also find generous lots, expansive lawns, guest houses, and some of the island's most impressive outdoor entertaining spaces.
Monomoy is perfect if you're looking for:
Cisco has become one of Nantucket's most desirable luxury destinations because it offers something many neighborhoods don't: a laid-back atmosphere without sacrificing beautiful homes.
The area is famous for Cisco Beach, surfing, Bartlett's Farm, Cisco Brewers, and some of the island's favorite casual restaurants. Many newer luxury homes feature contemporary coastal architecture, open floor plans, private pools, and generous outdoor living areas.
Cisco appeals to renters who want:
If privacy tops your wish list, Dionis deserves a look.
Located along Nantucket's quieter north shore, Dionis features large waterfront properties, winding roads, and some of the island's most secluded luxury estates. Many homes enjoy sweeping views of Nantucket Sound along with direct beach access and expansive grounds.
It's a neighborhood where you can spend an afternoon without seeing much traffic beyond cyclists and beachgoers.
Luxury renters love Dionis for:
Polpis feels a world away from the Town and the more populated areas.
Bordering Polpis Harbor and conservation land, this peaceful neighborhood offers a completely different luxury experience. Rather than being close to shopping and restaurants, Polpis offers quiet roads, open landscapes, harbor views, and remarkable natural beauty.
Many luxury homes here sit on substantial acreage with pools, guest cottages, and expansive outdoor spaces designed for entertaining or simply enjoying the scenery.
Polpis is best suited for guests looking for:
While every guest has different priorities, the island's premier rentals often share several characteristics:
The best homes also book surprisingly early, particularly in Cliff, Brant Point, Monomoy, and Dionis, where inventory is limited and repeat renters return year after year.
The best luxury rental isn't necessarily the largest or the most expensive. It's the one that matches how you want to spend your Nantucket summer.
If you want to walk everywhere, Brant Point is likely your ideal location. If privacy comes first, look toward Dionis or Polpis. For estate living close to Town, the Cliff remains one of the island's premier neighborhoods. If surfing, beaches, and a relaxed atmosphere sound like your perfect vacation, Cisco offers its own version of luxury. And if waterfront mornings and boating are high on your list, Monomoy deserves serious consideration.
Pro Tip: Many of Nantucket's premier homes are reserved 9 to 12 months in advance, particularly for July and August. If you have specific travel dates or must-have amenities like a pool or harbor views, it's worth starting your search early.
William Raveis Nantucket represents many of the island's finest exclusive luxury rentals, with homes across each of these sought-after neighborhoods. Whether you're planning a multi-generational family vacation or a summer escape with friends, working with a local team can help you find the right home before the best weeks are gone.
