241 Fenimore Street, Brooklyn (Prospect Leffert Gdn), NY, 11225 | $1,900,000

A Timeless Colonial Revival Gem in Prospect Lefferts Gardens

Welcome to 241 Fenimore Street, an enchanting three-story, two-family townhouse built in 1920 that exudes early 20th-century Colonial Revival charm. Nestled on a picturesque tree-lined street in the heart of Prospect Lefferts Gardens, this expansive home offers over 4, 500 square feet of living space, blending architectural beauty with modern functionality.

From the moment you step up to the covered front porch, you’ll be captivated by the home’s rich history. The meticulously preserved exterior, featuring large bay windows and charming wood details, sets the stage for what’s inside. Upon entry, you’re greeted by the original tile foyer, leading to the grand wooden staircase adorned with geometric carvings and stained-glass windows. The craftsmanship continues with hardwood floors and a decorative fireplace that graces the spacious formal living room.

The first floor boasts an open and inviting layout, from the formal living room to the grand dining area and a sun-drenched back living space. The large country kitchen pairs vintage appeal with modern convenience, featuring a fully operational O’Keefe & Merritt stove. A deck off the kitchen leads to a serene garden—perfect for relaxing or entertaining in your private outdoor oasis.

The original mahogany staircase takes you to the second level, where you’ll find an additional eat-in kitchen, another O’Keefe & Merritt stove, and an oversized primary bedroom with large bay windows. Two more bedrooms and a full bathroom round out this floor, with abundant natural light streaming through stained-glass windows.

Ascend to the third level, where three more bedrooms await, alongside a full bathroom and an attic space that could serve as a walk-in closet or even an eighth bedroom, offering endless possibilities.

The finished lower level of the home is far from an afterthought. Featuring a separate living space with a bedroom, full bathroom, and coffee nook, this area is ideal for extended family, guests, or potential rental income.

Situated just south of Prospect Park, this home offers the perfect blend of urban convenience and historic charm. Stroll through tree-lined streets and enjoy easy access to local favorites like Camillo and PLG Coffee House & Tavern. With Wholesome Foods Market and Lincoln Market just blocks away, everyday conveniences are at your doorstep.

Whether you’re drawn by the historical details, the ample living space, or the vibrant Prospect Lefferts Gardens neighborhood, 241 Fenimore Street is more than a home—it’s a piece of history.

Features